As educators, we are all too aware of how quickly retention rates
drop during a lecture. So we are going to give you the "Cliffs Notes"
version: Creatine works. It is extremely safe, improves explosive
performance and enhances muscle mass. Yawn.
OK, so you knew that. Now, let us get to the new and exciting info
on creatine. Research conducted over the past 16 months has uncovered
some pretty cool facts about the current king of anabolic supplements.
So grab your No. 2 pencils and take a seat. You are about to learn how
to get even better gains with creatine.
Creatine Is Safe
Let us start here, just in case you have encountered one of those
silly articles in the mainstream press that provides false information
about creatine. A Netherlands study found that almost one year of
continuous creatine supplementation had no adverse effects on kidney
function. The research states that of 175 healthy subjects taking
either 10 g per day of creatine or a placebo for 310 days, no
deleterious effects were noted on blood or urinary markers of kidney
function. While we are at it, we would also like to note that to date,
no placebo-controlled, double-blind studies in humans have ever
reported side effects from creatine supplementation. No cramping, no
muscle strains, no abnormal blood work, nothing. And remember, while
widespread creatine use began in the early 1990s, many athletes have
been using it since the 1960s, so there is a fairly substantial history
of safe use.
Take-home Lesson: Do not listen to disinformation. Creatine is safe. Period.
Creatine Gets High Grades
|
For
fitness-minded folks, creatine plays its most important roles in
skeletal muscle, where fast-twitch fibers can store about twice as much
creatine as slow-twitch fibers. The uptake process, like synthesis, can
be ramped up by several factors, such as exercise, catecholamines
(e.g., adrenaline), insulin-like growth factor-1, insulin and the
ingestion of carbohydrates and protein.
Many savvy supplement manufacturers have taken notice and now
incorporate creatine into nitric-oxide boosters, energy bars,
meal-replacement products, pre- and post-workout drinks and protein
powders. The truth is, not everyone needs an expensive creatine product
to enhance their performance, muscle strength and size.
For creatine "responders," a daily dose of 3–5 g mixed into fruit juice
or hot chocolate does wonders. But for others with sensitive stomachs
and/or limited ability to sponge up creatine into their muscles, the
more esoteric, scientifically based creatine blends are godsends. And
before anyone e-mails us, no - there are no head-to-head studies that
show one form of creatine is better than another … yet.
|
Add High-Gi Carbs
In a review of the scientific basis and practical aspects of
creatine supplementation for athletes, researchers from the University
of Connecticut noted that:
Creatine supplementation does indeed augment gains in muscle
strength and size during training, although the precise reason(s) why
are still unclear.
Creatine supplementation is most effective in improving short, repeated bursts of high-intensity activity.
By virtue of its ability to improve performance, creatine
supplementation increases training volume, which results in a greater
training stimulus.
Creatine induces cell swelling in muscle, which allows muscle to hold greater quantities of glycogen (stored carbohydrates).
Not everyone "responds" to creatine supplementation. For some
reason, individuals whose muscles do not absorb creatine very well
notice very little, if any, performance enhancement from creatine
supplementation.
Take-Home Lesson: An
effective strategy to increase creatine storage in muscle is to elevate
insulin levels during creatine ingestion (usually post-exercise) via
the ingestion of high-glycemic-index carbohydrates.
Go Heavy
Researchers from the University of Alberta characterized subjects who
benefit from creatine supplementation ("responders") and those who do
not ("nonresponders"). Responders have low initial
(pre-supplementation) levels of creatine in their muscles, a high
percentage of fast-twitch muscle fibers, and a large amount of fat-free
(lean) mass relative to body weight. These differences in biological
profiles between individuals help explain some of the equivocal
performance findings from creatine studies.
Take-Home Lesson: Practically
speaking, since lifting heavier weights relies on more fast-twitch
muscle fibers, this may also mean that training with heavy weights
during creatine supplementation might be more effective than training
with light ones.
Have A Meal
Five days of creatine supplementation (20 g per day) did not improve
performance during a single 30-second cycle sprint. In this study, the
creatine supplement was calorie-free and utilized sodium to increase
uptake into muscle.
Take-Home Lesson: Two points
here: First, as mentioned previously, creatine usually works best
during repeated efforts, not single events; and second, creatine uptake
often requires some help in the form of carbohydrates or protein. In
other words, take your creatine with a meal.
Fill Your Plate with Macronutrients
In a study of elderly men randomly assigned to either a placebo,
creatine plus carbs, or creatine plus carbs and protein, subjects who
ingested their creatine with carbs and protein gained the most lean
mass during 10 weeks of training. Strength gains, however, were similar
between all three groups.
Take-Home Lesson: Creatine works best at increasing lean mass when combined with protein and carbs. (There is a shocker.)
Earn Your "BA"
Creatine, either alone or in combination with beta-alanine (BA), a new
player in the supplement arena, enhances exercise performance. Forty
men supplemented with either creatine, creatine plus BA, BA only,
or placebo for 10 weeks. Both creatine and BA enhanced cycling
performance, but the combination was no more effective than either of
the two alone.
Take-Home Lesson: Still, beta-alanine has performed well in other studies, so this supplement is definitely worth taking for a test run.
Limit Java
Here is one that is bound to cause some controversy. Depending on the
type of exercise, caffeine may negate some of the performance-enhancing
effects of creatine. Subjects who ingested 40 g per day of creatine for
six days improved their performance during a series of three
leg-extension tests. However, when a single dose of approximately 350
mg of caffeine was given two hours prior to the same series of tests,
performance only improved in one of the leg-extension tests.
Take-Home Lesson: While we
are not overly concerned about caffeine and creatine combos, for now,
if you co-ingest creatine and caffeine, keep the dose of the latter
under 200 mg.
"To date, no placebo-controlled, double-blind studies in humans have reported side effects from creatine."
|
Creatine by Heart
Low-dose creatine supplementation, when combined with a multivitamin
for four weeks, lowers homocysteine levels in blood. You may have seen
this study reported on in the news, as it received quite a bit of
attention.
Take-Home Lesson: Since
elevated homocysteine levels are a risk factor for cardiovascular
disease, this indicates that creatine supplementation may be beneficial
for reducing the risk of cardiovascular disease in certain individuals.
Enhances Endurance
Creatine supplementation for five days before running a marathon
reduced exercise-induced cell damage and markers of inflammation by
20–60%. No cramping, dehydration or other side effects were noted, and
all runners completed the race close to, or better than, their personal
best.
Take-Home Lesson: Endurance
athletes can also gain from creatine. Previous research with endurance
exercise has revealed that creatine loading prior to carbohydrate
loading allows muscle to hold more carbohydrates.
"The
mountain of data supporting creatine and its benefits for athletes
continues to grow like a raging bonfire in a lumberyard."
|
Brain Aid
Researchers from Harvard Medical School noted that creatine has
remarkable neuroprotective properties in experimental models of
Huntington’s disease, Parkinsons disease and traumatic brain injury.
Take-Home Lesson: Regular use of creatine (similar to taking a baby aspirin every day) should be considered for patients at high risk for stroke.
Will Not Burn You Up
This study gauged the effects of using creatine in unusually hot
conditions. Regardless of whether the subjects loaded with creatine (20
g per day for five days) or a placebo, no differences in core
temperature or skin temperature were noted in 15 men who cycled for 40
minutes at 102 degrees Fahrenheit.
Take-Home Lesson: Creatine
supplementation does not impair thermoregulation during submaximal
exercise in heat. This flies in the face of certain smear tactics
against creatine that blamed this valuable supplement of contributing
to problems of overheating for some athletes. Once again, researchers
have bolstered the safety record of creatine.
Helps Prevent Muscle Wasting
Creatine loading reduces muscle wasting induced by immobilization.
Although this study was done on rats, it has sweeping implications for
anyone put in a cast or stuck in bed due to illness or injury. Rats
given creatine for seven days before and during a seven-day
immobilization period lost less muscle than control rats.
Take-Home Lesson: OK, this
is with rodents, but this study shows the promise creatine has for
muscle-wasting diseases, and how that promise could benefit healthy
exercisers.
There you have it! The mountain of data supporting creatine and its
benefits for athletes continues to grow like a raging bonfire in a
lumberyard. In our view, when used according to recommended guidelines,
creatine is one of the safest, most beneficial dietary supplements
available today. You can thank science (and lots of money spent on
research) for that.
Tim Ziegenfuss, PhD, is the president of Z Sciences, Inc., a widely
recognized consulting firm to the dietary supplement industry. Jamie
Landis, MD, PhD, is an assistant professor in the department of biology
at Lakeland Community College in Ohio. To obtain more details of the
studies cited in this article, e-mail Tim Ziegenfuss, PhD, at labinsider@physicalmag.com.
|